[Vision2020] Legislative Update 5

[Rep. Tom Trail]

LEGISLATIVE NEWSLETTER V—February 13-19/2011

Constituents:

     For those of you interested in the background of the history and
development of SPI Luna’s Educational Reform Plan, I have two
attachments which may be of interest to you.  The first came to me
from Gary Smith who has written about the connections and growing
influence of corporations targeting the education market.  The second
attachment traces the connections between SPI Luna, Bill Bennett’s
K-12 Education Company, and Tom Wolford, Executive Director of the
Albertson from Randy Stapilus.  There were also two major articles
about SPI Tom Luna's connection with the private educational
corporate world in the Idaho Statesman today.

 1.  Budget--The budget figures continue to change on almost a daily
basis.  The budget for FY12 is projected on an estimated 3 percent growth
rate.  It appears that there will be at this point potential cuts of
almost $80 million in public education, $10 million for Higher Education
and $35 million for Medicaid.

2.  Silence of the Lambs--The State Board of Education according to the
Idaho State Constitution is charged to provide for the general governance,
supervision, and control of all state educational institutions, and
control of all state educational system.  So where was the State Board
when SPI Luna made his announcement for major educational reform on
January 12th.  President of the Board, Russ Westerberg, when asked how
much involvement the Board had in the development of the Plan reported to
the combined House and Senate Education Committees, "None!!"   One has to
ask one’s self how a State Board of Education charged with oversight over
K-12 education never had a clue about the Luna Plan.  One would have
thought that Mr. Luna might have dropped a word or two to a board member
sometime before the announcement.  In the military they would have called
this "dereliction of duty."
    But then one has to remember who the Shepherd of the flock is.   None
of the Colleges of Education or Presidents of the Idaho    
institutions of Higher Education were ever consulted. The President of
the Idaho School Boards also stated, "We only learned about the Plan
when the announcement was made.  The same is true for the PTA and
School Administrators.  The evidence is overwhelming that none of the
key stakeholders in the education community were consulted.  The
entire process is, therefore, terribly flawed and the issue of "due
process" can certainly be brought forth.

 3. Are Idaho Taxpayers Subsidizing Large Corporation Megaloads on Highway
12?   This is a question that a group of us asked Idaho Dept. of
Transportation employees at a meeting in May.  Their answer was,  "there
is no way that the $2,000 per load permit can cover ITDs technical,
legal, and administrative costs."  I wrote ITDs Director, Brian Ness, in
November.  In a three page letter he indicated that such an analysis had
not yet been completed.  Since November I've made four further inquiries
to the question with no response.  I am forced to conclude that Idaho
taxpayer is subsidizing the cost of everyone of the megaloads traveling
on Highway 12.  There is also a question posed that the hundreds of
proposed megaloads may negatively impact the value of private property
along Highway 12.  Several real estate agents have made this claim. 
Therefore, it would seem reasonable that the International Corporations
should provide some compensation to property owners in the claim is
verified.  Estimates by some real estate agents indicate a drop in value
of property along Highway 12 of from 20-50%.  If this occurs then the
negative impact on property taxes for the counties will be substantial.

 4. Nullification--A bill supporting Idaho's right to Nullify the National
Health Care Plan passed the House on a 49-20 vote.  The Legislature
during the last session passed a Freedom from the National Health Care
Plan resolution.   Idaho was joined with more than 20 states and this
litigation is moving through the court system.  I supported the
resolution and we should leave it in the hands of our legal system.  In
the meanwhile both political parties agree that it is important to
provide medical insurance for 50 million uninsured.   Both parties also
agree on a number of components of the National Health Plan as being
beneficial to the country.  This is really the way we need to work rather
than fire off shots like supporting a nullification effort.  Idaho
Attorney Lawrence Wadsen issued an opinion that the nullification effort
was unconstitutional both at the National and State level and a violation
of a legislators’ oath of office in swearing to uphold the Constitution.
     I voted against the bill.  About 80 percent of constituents who
contacted me were opposed to the legislation.  If carried out to a
logical conclusion, cities and counties who receive unfunded mandates
from the State Legislature should be allowed claim nullification
rights as well.

 5.  HB111 which would have allowed tribal police officers to function as
police officers under state law if they have all of the required training
and insurance and cite all non-tribal criminal offenders into state court
and not tribal court was defeated by one vote.  The debate took over 2
hours.  The strange thing about this legislation is that relations with
the Coeur d’Alene Tribe and Kootenai law enforcement have been working
well for years but there are constant problems between the tribe and
Benewah County law enforcement and residents.   I received 175 e mails on
this bill but only three from Latah County.
      I voted for the bill.

 6.  There is a strong rumor circulating that SPI Tom Luna is positioning
himself for a run at the Governorship in 2014.

That's all for this week.    Please contact me with your comments and
recommendations.   My phone is 208 332-1184 and
e mail ttrail at house.idaho.gov

Rep. Tom Trail
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Gary Smiths Letter on the Luna Plan.docx
Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.documen
	t
Size: 32195 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman.fsr.com/pipermail/vision2020/attachments/20110220/cd5df0ea/attachment-0002.bin 
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Randy Stapilus letter.docx
Type: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.documen
	t
Size: 16376 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://mailman.fsr.com/pipermail/vision2020/attachments/20110220/cd5df0ea/attachment-0003.bin