[Vision2020] Ament & NSA
joekc at adelphia.net
joekc at adelphia.net
Wed Apr 26 16:06:08 PDT 2006
A lot has been said about what Ament said -- and when he said it. I am confident that he would take back some of it now if he had the chance. There is no defense for calling another person an "android."
Though Aaron (being a recently elected official) might regret the way that he said things prior to the election he would likely stand by the content of what he said: what he said, not the way that he said it. We elected Aaron -- in part -- on the basis of this content: of what he meant by what he said.
As Joan notes in her comments below, "The key word here is 'before'." Aaron made all his comments before the election. But we elected him anyway.
The only reason NSA got to the CUP stage in the first place is that a decision was made at the last meeting of the old council instead of at the first meeting of the new council. Ament has already missed out on one opportunity regarding the CUP. If he misses out on two, you try to convince me that something hasn't gone terribly wrong.
This is a very important issue. We need to hear the will of the people and the people elected Ament. To deny Ament's voice is to deny democracy -- as Doug F's own argument suggests.
Let's get a grip on the situation, folks. We already have a potential lawsuit by UI on our hands. Let's not make matters worse.
There is an interesting story in all this somewhere. I wouldn't be surprised if Nathan Alford responded to this post immediately.
---- Joan Opyr <joanopyr at moscow.com> wrote:
Greg Dickison has filed a public records request asking for, among
other things, recordings of Liberal Island, a radio talk show that
Aaron Ament hosted before he was elected to public office. The key
word here is "before." When Aaron announced his candidacy, he left
KRFP and stopped doing his radio show. Why? Conflict of interest.
It's bad form to run for office with a megaphone in your hand. Also,
the KRFP board (and the FCC) have rules about these sorts of things;
Aaron has cheerfully and correctly followed these rules.
About Gary Crabtree's questions regarding whether or not Aaron's
statements on Liberal Island should oblige him to recuse himself from
the New St. Andrews zoning vote: they're good questions, but the
answer is no. Unless Greg Dickison, Doug Farris, or Gary can point to
something/anything Aaron has said or done to disqualify himself in this
matter since he ceased to be a private citizen and became an elected
official, then there are no grounds for recusal.
I'll give you an example: for more than a decade, Jesse Helms was a
commentator on WRAL-TV in Raleigh, North Carolina. You complain about
Aaron having referred (on his radio show) to NSA as an education free
zone? Jesse Helms spouted off about miscegenation, the joys of
segregation, his hatred for gays, lesbians, non-Christians, and
Democrats, you name it. When he decided to run for the U. S. Senate,
he stepped down from his job at WRAL and became Candidate Helms rather
than Talk Show Helms. Not once during his four terms in the U. S.
Senate did he recuse himself from a vote on civil rights, on employment
nondiscrimination, on religious issues, gay and lesbian issues, AIDS
funding, or anything else about which he'd spoken as a TV commentator.
What grounds do Greg, Doug Farris, et al, have for demanding Aaron
recuse himself in the NSA matter? The personal opinions he expressed
as a private citizen? Not good enough. You might also, while you're
at it, ask Bob Stout to step aside on matters relating to Moscow's
police union -- he is strongly in favor of the police union and, in
fact, campaigned on this issue. Let's also Jon Weber to step aside on
matters related to appliance sales as he co-owns the Sears store. John
Dickinson could step aside if anything comes up having to do with the
Kenworthy, as he's the founder of Sirius Idaho Theatre, and Linda Pall
should never, ever speak on legal matters, as she's a practicing
attorney. As for Mayor Chaney, well, God help us if anything to do
with nursing should come before the City Council because she's a real
live RN. I'll bet she has strong opinions on the subject of decubitus
Finally, about recordings of Liberal Island -- until last fall, when
KRFP began podcasting over the Internet, the station did not (as far as
I know) record any of its programs. Not mine; not Aaron's; not even
Emily Poor's wonderful Americana show. If any recordings exist, it's
because friends recorded the show off the radio. I have copies of my
show because Tom Hansen very generously records it each and every week
and makes it available on the web for download. This means that my
grandmother in Raleigh can listen to me tell scandalous stories about
the family and do impersonations of her views in her accent. (I love
my grandmother to pieces, but she's often unintentionally hilarious.)
I am specifically named in Greg's public records request. He seems to
be under the impression that there's a broad conspiracy against NSA
involving Aaron and a bunch of unrelated folk -- I only know about half
of the people Greg has named in his PR request -- a conspiracy that
might have been preserved for time and eternity via recordings of
Liberal Island and Aaron's City of Moscow email account. As fishing
trips go, this one wouldn't pull up a tiddler. It's goofy thinking,
and it's paranoid -- it also reveals more about the inner workings of
Christ Church than any critique I've ever offered. But, to show that I
don't do conspiracies, that I have nothing to be ashamed of and
certainly nothing to hide, I'll make Greg an unconditional offer -- I
have two personal recordings of Liberal Island. One is Aaron's
interview with Bill London, dated April 5th, 2005. The other is
Aaron's interview with me. I went on Liberal Island in December of
2004 to talk about Moscow's 49% Rally, a protest that took place on
George W. Bush's second inauguration day. (If you want to know more
about the 49% Rally, either visit my website and go to the links page,
or Google your way through Dale Courtney's blog. He was at the rally,
typing notes and taking pictures.) I will send Greg copies of both of
these shows, and he can do with them what he will.
If he'd like a complete set of The Auntie Establishment and Brother
Carl Show, I'd be happy to send him that as well. Free of charge. We
play some damned good music on the show, I must say, and anyone with an
ear for melodious voices should be delighted to have the dulcet tones
of Brother Carl playing over his or her stereo. Carl is Moscow's
answer to Barry White.
Joan Opyr/Auntie Establishment
List services made available by First Step Internet,
serving the communities of the Palouse since 1994.
mailto:Vision2020 at moscow.com
More information about the Vision2020