[Vision2020] big Brother Reaching Out To You

[Art Deco]

  [image: The New York Times] <http://www.nytimes.com/>

------------------------------
August 5, 2013
T.S.A. Expands Duties Beyond Airport Security By RON
NIXON<http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/n/ron_nixon/index.html>

WASHINGTON — As hundreds of commuters emerged from Amtrak and commuter
trains at Union Station on a recent morning, an armed squad of men and
women dressed in bulletproof vests made their way through the crowds.

The squad was not with the Washington police department or Amtrak’s police
force, but was one of the Transportation Security Administration’s Visible
Intermodal Prevention and Response squads — VIPR teams for short — assigned
to perform random security sweeps to prevent terrorist attacks at
transportation hubs across the United States.

“The T.S.A., huh,” said Donald Neubauer of Greenville, Ohio, as he walked
past the squad. “I thought they were just at the airports.”

With little fanfare, the agency best known for airport screenings has
vastly expanded its reach to sporting events, music festivals, rodeos,
highway weigh stations and train terminals. Not everyone is happy.

T.S.A. and local law enforcement officials say the teams are a critical
component of the nation’s counterterrorism efforts, but some members of
Congress, auditors at the Department of Homeland Security and civil
liberties groups are sounding alarms. The teams are also raising hackles
among passengers who call them unnecessary and intrusive.

“Our mandate is to provide security and counterterrorism operations for all
high-risk transportation targets, not just airports and aviation,” said
John S. Pistole, the administrator of the agency. “The VIPR teams are a big
part of that.”

Some in Congress, however, say the T.S.A. has not demonstrated that the
teams are effective. Auditors at the Department of Homeland Security are
asking questions about whether the teams are properly trained and deployed
based on actual security threats.

Civil liberties groups say that the VIPR teams have little to do with the
agency’s original mission to provide security screenings at airports and
that in some cases their actions amount to warrantless searches in
violation of constitutional protections.

“The problem with T.S.A. stopping and searching people in public places
outside the airport is that there are no real legal standards, or probable
cause,” said Khaliah Barnes, administrative law counsel at the Electronic
Privacy Information Center in Washington. “It’s something that is easily
abused because the reason that they are conducting the stops is shrouded in
secrecy.”

T.S.A. officials respond that the random searches are “special needs” or
“administrative searches” that are exempt from probable cause because they
further the government’s need to prevent terrorist attacks.

Created in the aftermath of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the T.S.A. has
grown to an agency of 56,000 people at 450 American airports. The VIPR
teams were started in 2005, in part as a reaction to the Madrid train
bombing<http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/11/international/europe/11CND-TRAI.html>in
2004 that killed 191 people.

The program now has a $100 million annual budget and is growing rapidly,
increasing to several hundred people and 37 teams last year, up from 10
teams in 2008. T.S.A. records show that the teams ran more than 8,800
unannounced checkpoints and search operations with local law enforcement
outside of airports last year, including those at the Indianapolis 500 and
the Democratic and Republican national political conventions.

The teams, which are typically composed of federal air marshals, explosives
experts and baggage inspectors, move through crowds with bomb-sniffing
dogs, randomly stop passengers and ask security questions. There is usually
a specially trained undercover plainclothes member who monitors crowds for
suspicious behavior, said Kimberly F. Thompson, a T.S.A. spokeswoman. Some
team members are former members of the military and police forces.

T.S.A. officials would not say if the VIPR teams had ever foiled a
terrorist plot or thwarted any major threat to public safety, saying the
information is classified. But they argue that the random searches and
presence of armed officers serve as a deterrent that bolsters the public
confidence.

Security experts give the agency high marks for creating the VIPR teams.
“They introduce an unexpected element into situations where a terrorist
might be planning an attack,” said Rafi Ron, the former chief of security
for Ben-Gurion International Airport in Israel, who is now a transportation
security consultant.

Local law enforcement officials also welcome the teams.

“We’ve found a lot of value in having these high-value security details,”
said John Siqveland, a spokesman for Metro Transit, which operates buses
and trains Minneapolis-St. Paul. He said that local transit police have
worked with VIPR teams on security patrols on the Metro rail line, which
serves the Minnesota Vikings stadium, the Mall of America and the airport.

Kimberly Woods, a spokeswoman for Amtrak, said the railroad has had good
experiences with VIPR team members who work with the Amtrak police on
random bag inspections during high-travel times. “They supplement our
security measures,” she said.

But elsewhere, experiences with the teams have not been as positive.

In 2011, the VIPR teams were criticized for screening and patting down
people after they got off an Amtrak train in Savannah, Ga. As a result, the
Amtrak police chief briefly banned the teams from the railroad’s property,
saying the searches were illegal.

In April 2012, during a joint operation with the Houston police and the
local transit police, people boarding and leaving city buses complained
that T.S.A. officers were stopping them and searching their bags. (Local
law enforcement denied that the bags were searched.)

The operation resulted in several arrests by the local transit police,
mostly for passengers with warrants for prostitution and minor drug
possession. Afterward, dozens of angry residents packed a public meeting
with Houston transit officials to object to what they saw as an unnecessary
intrusion by the T.S.A.

“It was an incredible waste of taxpayers’ money,” said Robert Fickman, a
local defense lawyer who attended the meeting. “Did we need to have T.S.A.
in here for a couple of minor busts?”

Representative Bennie Thompson, Democrat of Mississippi and ranking member
on the House Homeland Security Committee, which has oversight of the
T.S.A., said he generally supports the VIPR teams but remains concerned
about the warrantless searches and the use of behavior detection officers
to profile individuals in crowds.

“This is a gray area,” he said. “I haven’t seen any good science that says
that is what a terrorist looks like. Profiling can easily be abused.”

Mr. Thompson said he also had questions about the effectiveness of the
program because of issues like those raised in Houston and Savannah.

“It’s hard to quantify the usefulness of these teams based on what we have
seen so far,” he said.

An August 2012 report by the inspector general of the Department of
Homeland Security raised similar questions.

Some T.S.A. officials told auditors that they had concerns that deploying
VIPR teams to train stations or other events was not always based on
credible intelligence.

The auditors also said that VIPR teams might not have “the skills and
information to perform successfully in the mass transit environment.”

Mr. Pistole said the agency is now retraining VIPR teams based on
recommendations in the report and is working to increase the public’s
knowledge about them.




-- 
Art Deco (Wayne A. Fox)
art.deco.studios at gmail.com
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.fsr.com/pipermail/vision2020/attachments/20130806/2f7e7c89/attachment.html>