[Vision2020] More N.C.A.A. ‘Justice’

[Sue Hovey]

I actually ran into a situation somewhat like this when I worked with WSU on their National Board Program for teachers.  For a candidate to be accepted into the program s/he has to show affidavits of 3 years of successful teaching.  One of my Pullman teachers left her school district when she was offered a contract in Pullman.   She had been on a one year contract, which she fulfilled. The district refused to sign telling her she didn’t give them notice of her leaving and they “planned to offer her a contract.”  Fortunately the National Board took the letter as evidence of successful teaching.  Some folks in positions of power are just plain mean.


Sue H.

From: Art Deco 
Sent: Saturday, January 14, 2012 7:30 AM
To: vision2020 at moscow.com 
Subject: [Vision2020] More N.C.A.A. ‘Justice’

 
a.. Reprints



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

January 13, 2012
More N.C.A.A. ‘Justice’
By JOE NOCERA
Last week’s case study in N.C.A.A. injustice took place at the University of North Carolina, where every sport is big time. Today, we move north to a different kind of institution, St. Joseph’s University, a small Jesuit-run school in Philadelphia. With fewer than 5,000 undergraduates, St. Joe’s doesn’t even field a football team, but its little-engine-that-could basketball team has long been a source of pride. During the 2003-4 season, for instance, it went 27-0 in the regular season and made it to the regional final of the N.C.A.A. championship tournament. 

In 2008, Todd O’Brien, a 7-foot center, transferred from Bucknell, where he had played as a freshman, to St. Joe’s. After sitting out a year, which the N.C.A.A. requires when a player switches schools, he played the next two seasons at St. Joe’s. His coach, Phil Martelli, gave him plenty of playing time in his first year, but in his second year the team struggled, O’Brien played poorly and he wound up mostly on the bench. 

He also graduated with a major in economics. Yet because of the year he sat out, he still had a year of athletic eligibility left — and he still wanted to play basketball. The athletic department’s academic advisers suggested that he delay graduation and fill his final year with courses like pottery, O’Brien told me. He had larger ambitions, however. He wanted to get a graduate degree in public administration. St. Joe’s didn’t have a suitable program, but O’Brien found one to his liking at the University of Alabama at Birmingham. The basketball coaching staff there was excited to have him join the team for his final season of college basketball. 

There was one problem, however. Even though O’Brien was a bench warmer, Martelli, O’Brien said, was furious when he found out the player was leaving. As O’Brien later recounted to Sports Illustrated, when he told his coach that he was going to be attending Alabama-Birmingham for graduate school, Martelli responded with an expletive-laced tirade, vowing to block him from finishing his course work, and even threatening to sue him. 

In a second meeting a few days later, according to O’Brien and his lawyer, Martelli told him that he would either “be playing at St. Joe’s next year or not playing anywhere.” O’Brien had already ascertained that there was no N.C.A.A. impediment to him playing for another school. It has a special rule for athletes like him — graduate students with remaining eligibility — allowing them to enroll in another university without having to sit out a year. The rule also states, though, that the player’s previous school has to agree to “release” him. St. Joe’s, clearly acting at Martelli’s behest, refused to sign the necessary paperwork. 

Let’s put aside the question of why college athletes usually have to sit out a year when they transfer, even though coaches can switch schools at the drop of a hat. That’s a column for another day. Let’s focus instead on O’Brien’s plight. How can a student who has graduated from one institution be prevented from participating in an extracurricular activity at a different school? How can a miffed coach’s pique control the activities of a student who doesn’t even play for him anymore? Can a music teacher who is angry at a violin student prevent him from playing in another school’s orchestra? The very idea is absurd. Why is it any less absurd when the student is an athlete? Why is it any less wrong? Yet that is precisely what the N.C.A.A.’s rules make possible. 

And which it then reinforces with its own iron fist. Unable to persuade St. Joe’s to change its mind, O’Brien appealed to the N.C.A.A. Did the N.C.A.A., which purports to care about the welfare of its “student-athletes,” take stern action against St. Joe’s? Of course not. 

In response to O’Brien’s appeal, St. Joe’s submitted a letter complaining, among other things, that his transfer was done for “athletic reasons” rather than academic ones. Though that clearly is untrue, so what if it had been? Why should his reason matter? Nevertheless, the N.C.A.A. sided with the school. An N.C.A.A. spokeswoman sent me a statement saying, “St. Joseph’s opposition was an important factor” in denying O’Brien’s request. Which only makes sense, since coaches, not athletes, are the N.C.A.A.’s real constituency. (She also said that the N.C.A.A. would review the case again this week.) For its part, St. Joe’s has refused to discuss the situation, citing “privacy laws.” 

In a column in The Wall Street Journal this week, Mark Emmert, the N.C.A.A. president, complained about unnamed critics who were calling for players to be paid — gee, who could he be referring to? — and said that the N.C.A.A. had to come up with solutions “that reflect our values.” Its real values are reflected in cases like Todd O’Brien’s. There are a hundred others just like his. 

Meanwhile, in Philadelphia, a small Catholic school has disgraced itself because it won’t stand up to its bully of a basketball coach. 






-- 
Art Deco (Wayne A. Fox)
art.deco.studios at gmail.com



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
=======================================================
List services made available by First Step Internet,
serving the communities of the Palouse since 1994.
               http://www.fsr.net
          mailto:Vision2020 at moscow.com
=======================================================
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.fsr.com/pipermail/vision2020/attachments/20120114/a53b0f4a/attachment.html>