[Vision2020] Schmear?

[keely emerinemix]

You raise a good point, Wayne -- if the information is true, it's not a "smear," necessarily, and certainly not libelous.  The motivation for making this information, already public record, even more public, and in the context of a campaign, is what would make it a smear.  Some hold to that argument -- clearly.  But when one is seeking electoral office, which entails not only some understanding of law and ethics, and ought to require at least a minimal level of smarts and integrity, it seems to me that Young's past troubles are appropriate to bring up.  

A candidate's medical records, past addictions now conquered, and religious convictions shouldn't be part of the debate -- unless those things, like religious views that would make working with those of other faiths difficult if not impossible, relate directly to his or her ability to be effective once in office.  An example of that  has been demonstrated in multi-media exuberance over the last month or so, and it's tainted the religious faiths involved, the candidate unwilling to distance himself from ugly bigotry and ignorance, and the entire political process.  

Young also has claimed that he's been "brainwashed" in the public schools, so it's reasonable to question -- vigorously -- how he might deal with funding for public education. Those questions, and whatever relevant information would educate the voters, ought to be the purview of the local print media.  But we're getting our information, in too many cases, from anonymous mailings -- which I deplore.  I have zero respect for people who holler loudly, or hint maliciously, and then hide behind anonymity or pseudonyms or false-flag groups.  Those who act so cowardly will continue, regardless of what kind of journalism we have here.  But the cowards often whisper -- or shout -- about things we ought to be hearing about from local reporters.  If we had something in Moscow even close to real journalism, these things would be the subject of robust investigation.  But all I've seen from the Daily News in the nearly nine years that I've lived here is a robust desire to ingratiate itself with the Kirk.  While it undoubtedly builds up the wine cellars of the editors involved, it certainly hasn't built up the citizenry of Moscow and the rest of Latah County.  

Keely
www.keely-prevailingwinds.com




From: deco at moscow.com
To: vision2020 at moscow.com
Date: Wed, 27 Oct 2010 08:24:28 -0700
Subject: [Vision2020] Schmear?










When is a smear a smear?
 
An article in yesterday's Daily News presents the 
claim that candidate Isaac Young was/is a 'victim' of an anonymous smear 
mailing.
 
First, I do not approve of anonymous political mailings; those 
who send them ought be held accountable at criminal and civil law.  To the 
extent that these mailings convey false information such 
mailings are counterproductive to the democratic process.
 
Having said that, has anyone seen the alleged smear mailing or 
have scan of it to share here?
 
>From the meager information given in the news article it 
appears that the some of the claims made in the mailing may be true.  

 
Excepting the anonymous method of communication, is such a 
mailing a smear if it gives truthful information?  Various voters consider 
all kinds of information when making a choice including candidates' past civil 
and criminal court actions.  Have we reached the point where we are so PC 
that a person's criminal or civil court record is off-base to political 
discussion?  
 
I hope not because along with media failures to adequately 
inform voters that's how we end up electing crooks, liars, crackpots, and the 
terminally dumb.

 
Wayne A. Fox
1009 Karen Lane
PO Box 9421
Moscow, ID  
83843
 
waf at moscow.com
208 
882-7975


=======================================================
 List services made available by First Step Internet, 
 serving the communities of the Palouse since 1994.   
               http://www.fsr.net                       
          mailto:Vision2020 at moscow.com
======================================================= 		 	   		  
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://mailman.fsr.com/pipermail/vision2020/attachments/20101027/6c4e05a1/attachment.html