[Vision2020] ACS: Mubita's enabler........ at it yet again...

[Andreas Schou]

> Andrea,
>
> Nice try, but your dead wrong.  The difference between murder and
> manslaughter is one of intent and premeditation.  To suggest that mubita's
> guilt is mitigated because none of his victims has YET contracted AIDS, is
> fallacious because it was his INTENT to put them at a serious risk of
> infection.  The intent to victimize was there regardless of whether or not
> any of his victims ultimately test positive.

Tony --

When you are talking about a "serious risk" of infection from
unprotected sex, you do realize that what you are saying is an
"serious risk" the CDC estimates to be between a 0.1% and 1% chance of
infection from a single incident of unprotected vaginal sex? I am not
saying that Kanay Mubita is a saint, or that there should be no
punishment for his actions, but you are applying a standard to HIV
that is applied to no other disease, including diseases that are far
more immediately fatal.

-- ACS