[Vision2020] )6-15-04 LA Times OP/ED: Tout Torture, Get Promoted

Tue, 15 Jun 2004 07:38:10 -0700

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------=_NextPart_000_000B_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
	boundary="----=_NextPart_001_000C_01C452AB.B58E65B0"

------=_NextPart_001_000C_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-scheer15jun15.story
COMMENTARY
Tout Torture, Get Promoted
Defending cruelty can be a career booster in Bush's administration.
By Robert Scheer

June 15, 2004

What a revelation to learn that the Justice Department lawyer who wrote the
infamous memo in effect defending torture is now a U.S. 9th Circuit Court of
Appeals judge. It tells you all you need to know about the sort of conservative
to whom George W. Bush is turning in his attempt to pack the federal courts.

Conservatives once were identified with protecting the rights of the individual
against the unbridled power of government, but this is not your grandfather's
conservatism. The current brand running things in D.C. holds that the commander
in chief is above all law and that the ends always justify the means. This has
paved the way for the increasingly well-documented and systematic use of torture
in an ad hoc gulag archipelago for those detained anywhere in the world under
the overly broad rubric of the "war on terror."

Those still clinging to the hopeful notion that photographic evidence of
beatings, dead detainees, sexual degradation and threats of electric shock were
all the work of a few twisted reservists aren't reading the newspapers. Press
accounts are following the paper trail up the chain of command to a heated and
lengthy debate inside the White House about how much cruelty constitutes
torture.

On Sunday, the Washington Post published on its website an internal White House
memo from Aug. 1, 2002, signed by then-Assistant Atty. Gen. Jay S. Bybee, which
argued darkly that torturing Al Qaeda captives "may be justified" and that
international laws against torture "may be unconstitutional if applied to
interrogations" conducted under President Bush. The memo then continued for 50
pages to make the case for the use of torture.

Was it as a reward for such bold legal thinking that only months later Bybee was
appointed to one of the top judicial benches in the country? Perhaps he was
anointed for his law journal articles bashing Roe vs. Wade and legal protection
for homosexuals, or for his innovative attack on the 17th Amendment to the
Constitution, which provides for the popular election of U.S. senators. But it's
hard to shake the notion that his memo to Counsel to the President Alberto
Gonzales established Bybee's hard-line credentials for an administration that
has no use for moderation in any form.

This president has turned his war on terror into an excuse for undermining due
process and bypassing Congress. For Bybee and his ideologue cohorts, however,
the American president is now more akin to a king, and legal or moral restraints
are simply problems that can be overcome later, if anybody bothers to question
the tactics: "Finally, even if an interrogation method might violate Section
2340A [of the U.S. Torture Convention passed in 1994], necessity or self-defense
could provide justification that would eliminate any criminal liability."

In fact, though, this was an argument of last resort for Bybee, whose definition
of torture "covers only extreme acts . where the pain is physical, it must be of
an intensity akin to that which accompanies serious physical injury such as
death or organ failure.. Because the acts inflicting torture are extreme, there
is [a] significant range of acts that, though they might constitute cruel,
inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, fail to rise to the level of
torture."

Bybee's generous standard should bring comfort to the totalitarian governments
that find the brutal treatment of prisoners a handy tool in retaining power or
fighting wars. Even Saddam Hussein, who always faced the threat of assassination
and terrorism from foreign and domestic rivals, can now offer in his defense
Bybee's memo that his actions were justifiable, on the grounds of "necessity or
self-defense."

When confronted by the Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee with the
content of Bybee's torture defense, Atty. Gen. John Ashcroft responded that the
memo did not guide the administration. Yet, the Bybee memo was clearly the basis
for the working group report on detainee interrogations presented to Defense
Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld a year later. And if Bybee's work was rejected as
reprehensible, why was he rewarded - with Ashcroft's deepest blessings - with a
lifetime appointment on the judicial bench only one level below the Supreme
Court?

Frighteningly, the Bybee memo is not some oddball exercise in moral relativism
but instead provides the most coherent explanation of how this administration
came to believe that to assure freedom and security at home and abroad, it
should ape the tactics of brutal dictators.

*

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Scheer writes a weekly column for The Times and is coauthor of "The Five
Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq" (Seven Stories Press/Akashic Books, 2003).

If you want other stories on this topic, search the Archives at
latimes.com/archives.

Article licensing and reprint options

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Copyright 2004 Los Angeles Times

------=_NextPart_001_000C_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: text/html;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN">
<HTML><HEAD>
<META http-equiv=3DContent-Type content=3D"text/html; =
charset=3Diso-8859-1">
<META content=3D"MSHTML 6.00.2800.1400" name=3DGENERATOR>
<STYLE></STYLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff>
<DIV><FONT size=3D4>
<DIV align=3Dcenter><A href=3D"http://www.latimes.com/"><IMG height=3D38 =

alt=3Dlatimes.com =
src=3D"http://www.latimes.com/images/standard/lat_both.gif"=20
width=3D205 vspace=3D3 border=3D0></A> </DIV>
<HR noShade SIZE=3D3>
<A=20
href=3D"http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-scheer15jun15.story">ht=
tp://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-scheer15jun15.story</A>=20

<H4>COMMENTARY</H4>
<H1>Tout Torture, Get Promoted</H1>
<H2>Defending cruelty can be a career booster in Bush's =
administration.</H2>By=20
Robert Scheer June 15, 2004 What a revelation to learn =
that the=20
Justice Department lawyer who wrote the infamous memo in effect =
defending=20
torture is now a U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals judge. It tells you =
all you=20
need to know about the sort of conservative to whom George W. Bush is =
turning in=20
his attempt to pack the federal courts. Conservatives once were=20
identified with protecting the rights of the individual against the =
unbridled=20
power of government, but this is not your grandfather's conservatism. =
The=20
current brand running things in D.C. holds that the commander in chief =
is above=20
all law and that the ends always justify the means. This has paved the =
way for=20
the increasingly well-documented and systematic use of torture in an ad =
hoc=20
gulag archipelago for those detained anywhere in the world under the =
overly=20
broad rubric of the "war on terror." Those still clinging to the =
hopeful=20
notion that photographic evidence of beatings, dead detainees, sexual=20
degradation and threats of electric shock were all the work of a few =
twisted=20
reservists aren't reading the newspapers. Press accounts are following =
the paper=20
trail up the chain of command to a heated and lengthy debate inside the =
White=20
House about how much cruelty constitutes torture. On Sunday, the=20
Washington Post published on its website an internal White House memo =
from Aug.=20
1, 2002, signed by then-Assistant Atty. Gen. Jay S. Bybee, which argued =
darkly=20
that torturing Al Qaeda captives "may be justified" and that =
international laws=20
against torture "may be unconstitutional if applied to interrogations" =
conducted=20
under President Bush. The memo then continued for 50 pages to make the =
case for=20
the use of torture. Was it as a reward for such bold legal =
thinking that=20
only months later Bybee was appointed to one of the top judicial benches =
in the=20
country? Perhaps he was anointed for his law journal articles bashing =
Roe vs.=20
Wade and legal protection for homosexuals, or for his innovative attack =
on the=20
17th Amendment to the Constitution, which provides for the popular =
election of=20
U.S. senators. But it's hard to shake the notion that his memo to =
Counsel to the=20
President Alberto Gonzales established Bybee's hard-line credentials for =
an=20
administration that has no use for moderation in any form. This =
president=20
has turned his war on terror into an excuse for undermining due process =
and=20
bypassing Congress. For Bybee and his ideologue cohorts, however, the =
American=20
president is now more akin to a king, and legal or moral restraints are =
simply=20
problems that can be overcome later, if anybody bothers to question the =
tactics:=20
"Finally, even if an interrogation method might violate Section 2340A =
[of the=20
U.S. Torture Convention passed in 1994], necessity or self-defense could =
provide=20
justification that would eliminate any criminal =
liability." In=20
fact, though, this was an argument of last resort for Bybee, whose =
definition of=20
torture "covers only extreme acts =85 where the pain is physical, it =
must be of an=20
intensity akin to that which accompanies serious physical injury such as =
death=20
or organ failure=85. Because the acts inflicting torture are extreme, =
there is [a]=20
significant range of acts that, though they might constitute cruel, =
inhuman or=20
degrading treatment or punishment, fail to rise to the level of=20
torture." Bybee's generous standard should bring comfort to the=20
totalitarian governments that find the brutal treatment of prisoners a =
handy=20
tool in retaining power or fighting wars. Even Saddam Hussein, who =
always faced=20
the threat of assassination and terrorism from foreign and domestic =
rivals, can=20
now offer in his defense Bybee's memo that his actions were justifiable, =
on the=20
grounds of "necessity or self-defense." When confronted by the =
Democrats=20
on the Senate Judiciary Committee with the content of Bybee's torture =
defense,=20
Atty. Gen. John Ashcroft responded that the memo did not guide the=20
administration. Yet, the Bybee memo was clearly the basis for the =
working group=20
report on detainee interrogations presented to Defense Secretary Donald =
H.=20
Rumsfeld a year later. And if Bybee's work was rejected as =
reprehensible, why=20
was he rewarded =97 with Ashcroft's deepest blessings =97 with a =
lifetime=20
appointment on the judicial bench only one level below the Supreme=20
Court? Frighteningly, the Bybee memo is not some oddball exercise =
in=20
moral relativism but instead provides the most coherent explanation of =
how this=20
administration came to believe that to assure freedom and security at =
home and=20
abroad, it should ape the tactics of brutal dictators. * 
<HR width=3D"20%">
Robert Scheer writes a weekly column for The Times and is coauthor of =
"The=20
Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq" (Seven Stories Press/Akashic =
Books,=20
2003). 
<DIV class=3Dcopyright align=3Dcenter>If you want other stories on this =
topic,=20
search the Archives at <A=20
href=3D"http://www.latimes.com/archives">latimes.com/archives</A>. <A =

href=3D"http://www.latimes.com/copyright" target=3D_new><IMG =
style=3D"MARGIN-TOP: 5px"=20
height=3D21 alt=3D"TMS Reprints"=20
src=3D"http://www.latimes.com/images/standard/tmsreprints_bug.gif" =
width=3D92=20
border=3D0></A><BR><A href=3D"http://www.latimes.com/copyright" =
target=3D_new>Article=20
licensing and reprint options</A><BR></DIV><BR><BR>
<HR noShade SIZE=3D3>

<DIV class=3Dcopyright align=3Dcenter><BR>Copyright 2004 Los Angeles =
Times <BR>
<SCRIPT language=3DJavaScript>=0A=
 var st_v=3D1.0; var st_pg=3D""; var st_ci=3D"703";=0A=
 var st_di=3D"d001"; var st_dd=3D"st.sageanalyst.net";=0A=
 var st_tai=3D"v:1.2.1";=0A=
 var st_ai=3D"2773574";=0A=
</SCRIPT>

<SCRIPT language=3DJavaScript1.1><!--=0A=
 st_v=3D1.1;=0A=
//--></SCRIPT>

<SCRIPT language=3DJavaScript1.2><!--=0A=
 st_v=3D1.2;=0A=
//--></SCRIPT>

<SCRIPT language=3DJavaScript1.1 src=3D"//st.sageanalyst.net/tag-703.js">=0A=
</SCRIPT>

<SCRIPT language=3DJavaScript>=0A=
 if (st_v=3D=3D1.0) {=0A=
  var st_uj;=0A=
  var st_dn =3D (new Date()).getTime();=0A=
  var st_rf =3D escape(document.referrer);=0A=
  st_uj =3D "//"+st_dd+"/"+st_dn+"/JS?ci=3D"+st_ci+"&di=3D"+st_di+=0A=
  =
"&pg=3D"+st_pg+"&rf=3D"+st_rf+"&jv=3D"+st_v+"&tai=3D"+st_tai+"&ai=3D"+st_=
ai;=0A=
  var iXz =3D new Image();=0A=
  iXz.src =3D st_uj;=0A=
 }=0A=
</SCRIPT>
<NOSCRIPT><IMG=20
src=3D"http://st.sageanalyst.net/NS?ci=3D703&amp;di=3Dd001&amp;pg=3D&amp;=
ai=3D2773574"></NOSCRIPT></DIV></FONT></DIV></BODY></HTML>

------=_NextPart_001_000C_01C452AB.B58E65B0--

------=_NextPart_000_000B_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: image/gif;
	name="lat_both.gif"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://www.latimes.com/images/standard/lat_both.gif
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------=_NextPart_000_000B_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: image/gif;
	name="tmsreprints_bug.gif"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://www.latimes.com/images/standard/tmsreprints_bug.gif
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------=_NextPart_000_000B_01C452AB.B58E65B0
Content-Type: application/octet-stream;
	name="NS?ci=703&di=d001&pg=&ai=2773574"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Location: http://st.sageanalyst.net/NS?ci=703&di=d001&pg=&ai=2773574

R0lGODlhAQABAIAAAP///wAAACwAAAAAAQABAAACAkQBADs=

------=_NextPart_000_000B_01C452AB.B58E65B0--